Talent Management in the global, digital economy
As organizations grapple with labour shortages, skills mismatch, and changing needs, Human Resources (HR) is elevated to a core strategic function of business. Talent acquisition and retention need to be tied in with the strategic plan of the business. Talent management is a core component of business performance and competitiveness. Companies must anticipate current and future hiring needs. But they must also nurture existing employees and position themselves as employers of choice to remain competitive in the race for talent.
In this chapter
5.1.1 Align talent management and business strategy
Regardless of the size of your business, talent management should be integrated into business, sales and growth strategy. If your goal is to take a new product to market in six months, think about what kind of sales support or brand management needs to be done, as well as the need for technical expertise and other skillsets.
5.1.2 Establish processes to counter uncertainty
It takes both skill and diplomacy to keep disparate interests in line when managing long-term employees, consultants, remote workers and international business partners. Implement processes to help guide work flows, communicate information effectively and empower people to make decisions in their individual roles.
PwC’s 2017 M&A Integration Survey report suggests “clarifying authority and assigning accountability” go a long way to “mitigating the crippling effects of uncertainty.”30
5.1.3 Match employee and customer brand
Just as you define your company’s unique product or service offering for clients, you need to determine what you will offer as an employer that is unique. Here are some ideas:
Culture – Define your corporate culture and the desired behaviours within your company. Identify people within the company who will role model cultural best practices.
Treat employees like your best customers - Provide incentives for those who promote and exemplify your company culture and strive for excellence.
Monitor and implement employee ideas – The best companies listen to their employees and have systems in place to check in frequently to see how established processes are working at the operational level.
Employees as ambassadors – Just as your sales people must go out and market products or services of your company, you want employees to be touting your firm as a great place to work. Done right, all employees are willing recruiters for your firm. Executives will enthusiastically recruit people from their networks to join the company ranks.31
5.1.4 Hire for potential, not experience
Too often, organizations focus on meaningless functions of a job when creating a job description. This is particularly moot as jobs become more cross-functional and changeable and the future of work unpredictable. Determine what skills are essential to a position and what can be acquired. Half of today’s jobs don’t require the high-level of specialization that are assigned to them in job postings.
According to Adam Robinson, founder of Chicago-based software firm, Hireology, it’s quite possible the next person you hire won’t have experience in your industry. Instead, he advises, look for four characteristics:
- A good attitude
- Accountability
- Past job success
- Cultural fit32
Focus on the top transferable skills – communication, collaboration, critical thinking and creativity.
Keep talent close because “good people are going to have an easier time finding work elsewhere.”
5.1.5 Offer opportunities for progression, beyond promotion
In its 2017 survey of Canadian employees, recruitment firm Hays Canada found there was a mismatch between employer offerings and the desires of employees.
Employers make a mistake when they equate career progression with promotion or a salary increase, says Rowan O’Grady, President of Hays Canada. “Career progression for most is the chance to feel they are moving forward or developing in their careers,” says O’Grady.
For many, this means learning new things or working on new projects or being empowered to make decisions within their role. Good talent management requires mapping of individual employee development to determine how they can achieve their professional goals to progress within your company.
For small firms, there are opportunities for development that don’t require spending a lot of money:
Have employees mentor or train each other.
When employees return from a conference or course, ask them to hold a lunch ‘n’ learn to teach others on the team. Or perhaps an employee has an interest they’ve been pursuing outside of work, like “using social media for business.” Can that employee design a short session to share with others?
Allow employees lateral movement.
Sometimes people stagnate in their current roles because there is no challenge. Depending on the structure and size of your company, consider allowing people on your team to swap roles. A job rotation opens up the possibility of learning new things. And it benefits your company. People who are presented with new challenges tend to be more innovative. Those with cross-functional experience are more likely to be future leaders.
5.1.6 Partner with local education and research institutions.
Companies that make a point of offering co-operative education programs and internships for students position themselves well to handpick individuals from the future talent pool. But there are many other ways you can get involved in academia to help shape and influence the skillsets of your future workers:
- Get involved with your industry associations and find out what they’re doing to partner with academic institutions and to ensure students are learning the skills you need for your business.
- Join a college or university advisory committee for the programs that are graduating workers in your field. These advisory committees welcome input from the business community and often ask for feedback and advice when updating and improving the curriculum.
- Consider offering a scholarship or award for students best demonstrating the skills or potential that your industry needs.
- Contact your local college or university and ask if you can create a comprehensive “real-life” assignment for the students in your desired program. While supporting the set curriculum, make sure the assignment is multi-faceted and covers a number of aspects of the discipline. Help mark and judge the assignments (ask your industry association to help) and perhaps offer a trophy or monetary award to the best-in-class.
5.1.7 Get creative around incentives
One of the biggest advantages of the digital economy is that it offers employers and employees flexibility around how and where work is done. The old work-life balance cliché has given way to a new way of working for many people, where work and personal lives are intertwined. As a result, competing for top talent doesn’t always have to be about salaries. Here are a few non-monetary incentives offered by top employers, driven by the demands of a younger, nimble workforce:
- Flex-time and work-from-home options
- Employee recognition events
- Friendly internal competitions or team social events
- Opportunities to represent the company at associations or conferences
In 2005, we hired our first full-time work-from-home. Now three-quarters of our delivery capability are individuals working from home. We were early adopters of this talent acquisition model.
5.1.8 Make the case for diversity
The demand for talent is so immense that efforts should be made to diversity your workforce. Diverse employees make your company more innovative, as a greater range of backgrounds and talents can lead to a greater exchange of ideas. A diverse workforce is also more likely to more accurately reflect the needs of your customers and clients, particularly if you’re selling internationally.
There’s a great business case to push for diverse hiring practices as well. It’s long been known that companies with diverse leaders actually make more money. More than a decade ago, think-tank Catalyst conducted a study over five years and found that companies with three or more women directors “outperformed those with zero women directors by 84% on return on sales, 60% on return on investment capital and 46% on return on equity.”33
In March 2018, Bank of Canada Governor Stephen Poloz made the economic case for getting more women, young people, Indigenous people and new Canadians and people with disabilities into the job market. Concerted efforts to do this, says Poloz, could expand the labour force by half a million people, and raise the country’s output by 1.5% or $30 billion annually.
5.1.9 Embrace technology and technology specialists
Technology adoption can streamline processes, and improve productivity and efficiency of individual workers. It’s worth thinking about the investment into technology and the skilled people you will need to implement it early on. The smaller the company – and indeed, the tighter the margins – the more the catalyst exists to adopt new technologies to remain competitive.
IT is a core part of business operations that drive sales. IT is often relegated as a support arm to the organization. To be competitive, you need to have digital technologies front and centre in all functions of the organization. This means bringing IT specialists and leaders to the planning table.
5.1.10 Support establishment of international operations
If you can’t get the skilled professionals you need to come to you, go to them. By setting up international operations in strategic markets, be it a branch office, help centre, or manufacturing plant, in countries where you operate, you can access the talent you need. Keep in mind that you may also be able to set up international operations virtually.
Pythian Group Inc. opens branch office in India to find new talent
In 1997, Paul Vallée recognized that the internet provided a huge opportunity to build a remote workforce that enabled technology services to be delivered globally, regardless of where employees were situated.
“Right from the beginning, Pythian was designed as an export business,” says Vallée. “I wanted to live in Ottawa but sell in New York.”
“We realized that we had reached the point where we could unpack the power of the internet to create a global company,” said Vallée.
“It worked well because the people I needed were here, in Canada.”
Twenty-one years later, Pythian is a global technology company that helps companies leverage disruptive data technologies to better compete. They have 400 employees in 35 countries, with clients ranging from financial institutions to gaming companies. The company tripled the size of its Ottawa headquarters in 2017, despite having well-established “work-from-anywhere” infrastructure in place for employees.
Vallée would be the first to tell you that a careful talent acquisition and development strategy have been essential to his global success. But by 2002, he realized local talent was tapped out.
“All the people that I wanted to work for me were either already working for me or they had worked for me and had moved on,” says Vallée. On top of that, as his company was selling to markets in Australia and Asia, staff were finding it difficult to offer around-the-clock customer service.
“We decided to open an office in India,” Vallée says. “It was unusual to set up a subsidiary at the time. Now it’s more common.”
Vallée and a senior colleague went to India and engaged a local boutique accounting shop as a starting point. They hired a realtor, visited office space, engaged a local contractor to renovate and provision desks. Within a few months, and at very little relative cost (about $50,000), they had a small office established in India with a local employee and one person on a temporary secondment from Ottawa.
“It was so easy,” says Vallée. “The accountant who helped us get started is still our India accountant in 2018.”
In addition to Canada and India, Pythian has offices in London, New York, San Francisco, and Sydney, Australia.
Be prepared to compensate specialized employees.
You need to be prepared to offer competitive terms for IT-centred employees. If the average salary in the ICT sector is $77,000 per year, can you match or exceed it? If not, what else can you offer in terms of compensation? Be creative. Vacation time, work hours, flex-time, travel, volunteer work and benefits are key components of a compensation package to help you to recruit top talent in this field.
5.1.11 Use government programs to make international recruitment part of your growth strategy.
The federal government has made it easier to hire international talent through the Global Talent Streams introduced in 2017. Companies in the ICT sector are already using it with great success. For companies outside the sector, be prepared with a list of selling points when trying to win candidates over. Just because a job’s available, it doesn’t mean a potential hire wants to move to Calgary or rural New Brunswick. Innovation clusters aside, Canada may not be as appealing for in-demand candidates as bustling innovation hubs like Silicon Valley, where there are more opportunities for candidates to move from company to company and create bigger networks.
“We have stranded risk in Canada,” says Morouney at the Lazaridis Institute. “To attract someone away from the valley, we need to consider what we have to offer besides money. Ultimately, we need to create a critical mass of companies.”
5.2.1 Identify and invest in young employees that demonstrate leadership potential
Diversity training, mentorship programs, participation in global projects and international assignments can help those in the C-Suite or on-track to management fortify their international business leadership skills.
5.2.2. Expand executive networks
Lazaridis Institute for the Management of Technology Enterprises has developed a scale-up program for technology companies. It selects 10 high-potential tech firms to participate in an international training and networking program each year that involves regular mentorship opportunities for start-up executives.
“Getting people in the same room for that knowledge transition is huge,” says Bryan Bogensberger, Associate Director and Executive Fellow, Lazaridis Institute. “We meet once per month in a different North American city, and bring in six to eight experts with international experience. It’s not just CEOs from the scale-up program that participate. Some companies will bring five executives for a weekend. It gets them out of the day-to-day running of the business to get some really valuable information from a peer-to-peer network.”
5.2.3. Look outside
If your leadership team is strong in certain areas, but lacking in others, it may be worth recruiting someone from outside the business who can round out your team.
“Don’t be afraid to search internationally if you can’t find the talent in Canada,” says Bogensberger. “Create an advisory board early on that have big networks, so you can fill the holes when you need to.”
People from other countries bring cultural awareness and best business practices from your target markets. They also bring their international business networks, which can help your entire executive team grow.
5.2.4. Engage an executive recruiter – sometimes one person makes all the difference.
As a founder of four start-ups, himself, and the current CEO of Quiver, Bogensberger recognizes it can be hard for some companies as they’re scaling up to consider putting up money for “the big hire.”
In Canada, it can be difficult to find expertise in international branding and marketing, he says.
“Engaging a recruiter to help fill that really key position makes a difference,” he says. “We’re averse to this in the start-up world – paying someone $60k to find you an executive. But as you scale up, you have to change your mindset.”
5.2.5. “Rent” an executive.
For smaller companies that require executive talent but don’t yet have the capacity to hire fulltime, a managers’ corporation may fill the gap. These businesses maintain a roster of seasoned executives and consultants from multiple professions, including business operations, growth strategy, intellectual property strategy, IT, finance, human resources and many others. Depending on your needs, you can hire on contract one or a team of professionals to advise you on a single project or for longer-term requirements.
5.2.6. Encourage risk
“In my mind, most executives fear going international because they don’t know what’s involved,” says global business consultant Mel Sauvé at Global Growth Results. “It’s high risk and they’re not sure they can do it. When I’m working with execs the first thing I do is convince them that it’s not that hard to do.”
Sauvé says it’s often a lack of understanding about foreign markets, tariffs or international business practices that intimidate executives. Hiring a consultant can help you get started. Sauvé says companies may not realize there’s a lot of free information available through the Trade Commissioner Service or Export Development Canada. He helps his clients to build an international growth plan by arming them with information about the unknown.
“You can’t teach risk-taking,” says Sauvé. “You just have to get comfortable with it.”
5.2.7. Boost international experience.
To succeed in international markets, executives need to develop what global strategy consultant Amy Karam calls a “cultural IQ” in every country where they do business.
Karam, author of The China Factor, explains that many cultural and business nuances can’t be understood from afar; some countries, for example, have much longer sales life cycle than Canadians may be used to.
“That has to be understood and incorporated into strategic expansion plans and at the micro level to set sales expectations,” she says.
And in Asian countries, like Japan, Korea and China, client and relationship-building takes a long time. “They really need to get to know you, trust you and like you before they’ll sign a purchase order. That may require a lot of trips to Japan to drink sake.”
To succeed internationally, the executives need to get out of the office. “The most successful executives spend time abroad, in market,” Karam advises.
Filling the gaps – the rise of the gig worker
One way employers are managing the skills shortage is by using consultants. It’s estimated independent workers – also known as consultants, freelancers and gig workers – will make up 30% or more of the workforce for one-quarter of firms worldwide within the next two years.34
There are many benefits to using gig workers. They can be brought in to fill gaps when your firm is scaling up quickly or working on a specific project. Consultants often bring with them a breadth of expertise or specialized knowledge that’s difficult to find in the general labour pool.
The rise of the gig economy, however, has a significant impact on how you manage talent. For one consultants can drive up salary expectations of your regular employees.
A study by EY Global notes a number of other challenges:
- The contingent workforce doesn’t have the same accountabilities as employees
- Firms must manage multiple vendor management systems
- Gig workers don’t fit into automated talent management processes
“There are also a number of risks relating to employment law and regulatory compliance, as well as the security of information, intellectual property and cyber security,” the authors write.
And don’t presume gig workers are looking to stay on for the long term. More than half of consultants surveyed by EY Global said they preferred self-employment to staying with one firm for the long haul.35
SUMMARY: Competing for talent in the global, digital economy
- In the competition for top talent, human resources (HR) needs to be a core component of business strategy
- Clarifying authority and assigning accountability go a long way toward keeping employees happy. This goes a long way toward retaining talented employees
- Offer current and prospective employees a unique value proposition for working for your company – the same way you would for your customers
- Hiring for the potential an employee would bring to your company is more important than the experience they already have
- Employees don’t just care about promotions. Opportunities to be mentored and trained or move horizontally into new roles can go a long way toward retaining top talent.
- Partnering with local education and research institutions can help recruit top students
- Money isn’t everything. If your company can’t afford to pay higher salaries, consider offering other incentives such as the option to work from home and team social events
- Hiring a diverse workforce leads to a greater exchange of ideas, which helps boost innovation and – ultimately – the bottom line
- Investing in technology needs to be a key consideration as your company grows
- Going global can help to recruit and retain talented employees
Boosting your executive pool to drive international growth
- Identify and invest in current employees who demonstrate leadership ability
- Build networking opportunities for executives from different companies to learn and grow with each other
- Recruiting executive talent from outside your company is a great way to fill in shortages in skills and experience
- An executive recruiter may be expensive up front, but can pay off huge dividends in the long-term if it helps you to attract the right candidate
- Managers’ corporations now allow companies (particularly smaller organizations) to “rent” seasoned executives on a part-time basis. This reduces long-term costs and gives you more flexibility in retaining executives who help to fill in a specialized area
- Encouraging executives to take risk is essential to going global
- Boosting international experience of individual executives will help your company build the knowledge needed to expand – both domestically and overseas
Canada is facing a talent gap. And if Canadian companies don’t find a way to close it, they’ll quickly fall behind their competitors on the global stage.
In this e-book we explored the reasons for the talent shortage and methods Canadian companies can use to overcome it.
But, in the end, solving the talent shortage will depend on another Canadian trait: innovation.
Companies that find a compelling method for recruiting and retaining top talent in key positions will find the most success. Those that don’t will quickly fall behind.
Think of it this way: So many companies are constantly evaluating and refining their unique value proposition in the market where their goods and services are sold.
Where they spend less time, though, is on defining that unique value proposition for their current and prospective employees.
But if you can make your company a compelling place to work, where employees feel valued, you’ll quickly find you can compete in the global war for talent.
Your success in going global will depend on it.